Mini update. Talked with the shop yesterday. Sounds like the adjuster is willing to work with them so they don't have to total the car. He said they were going to try to get a used bumper to save on costs. I laughed and told him good luck, but if it keeps them from having to total the car, I'm fine with it. Sounds like there isn't any mechanical damage. Hoping to officially hear back from the other insurance company today. Oh, and I did tell them to save parts.
Justin